River Diversion / Run-of-River
What is “Run-of-River” Hydropower?
The majority of new hydropower projects being constructed in BC are “Run-of-River.” The term “Run-of-River” brings to mind images of small turbines turning in a river to generate low-impact electricity, but the term “river diversion” more accurately describes these projects. Electricity is generated by diverting a large proportion (up to 95%) of a river’s flow into a tunnel or pipeline to power turbines before returning the water to the river further downstream. Turbines are not installed in the river itself.
River diversion projects range in size, but each one requires significant infrastructure including:
- A dam to create a small reservoir (known as a headpond),
- A pipeline or tunnel (known as a penstock) that can be several kilometres long to deliver water from the headpond to the turbines,
- A powerhouse building, to house the generators,
- A tailrace channel through which the diverted water is returned to the river,
- Access roads to the headpond and powerhouse,
- Transmission lines from the powerhouse to the nearest BC Hydro transmission line, and
- In some cases, an electrical substation.
- Each project leaves a “diversion reach” —the section of river between the dam and the powerhouse that water has been diverted from.
In some cases river diversion hydropower can be less environmentally damaging than traditional hydro projects that require enormous dams and reservoirs, and flood prime valley-bottom habitats. However, some river diversion projects, such as the cluster of 17 individual diversions proposed for Bute Inlet, are massive and would have significant environmental impacts. And some smaller projects (e.g. Kokish hydro project) can still have large impacts on fish and wildlife habitat.
The impacts of river diversion projects on terrestrial and aquatic habitats can be significant, but when done properly, with care given to footprint size and location these projects can generate electricity that minimizes impacts to the surrounding environment and nearby communities. However, current environmental review and approval processes in BC need major improvements to ensure that inappropriate projects are not approved and that the cumulative impacts of multiple projects do not result in unacceptable harm to rivers and surrounding landscapes.
Because river diversion hydro projects do not create large reservoirs, they only produce electricity during periods of high streamflow. Unfortunately, BC’s demand for electricity is highest during the coldest months of winter, when streamflows in BC are lowest. When river diversion hydro projects are not producing power, we must rely on our large dams, and when river diversions are producing power, it becomes necessary to refill the large dams. Therefore, large scale “run-of-river” hydropower development is not feasible without having enough large dams or other sources of “firm” power to buffer the intermittent power production caused by seasonal changes in streamflow.
Watershed Watch has been working to increase public awareness about the risks and benefits of river diversion hydropower, and the need for better planning, assessment, and monitoring of this industry in BC. We also work with other groups to provide expert comments on proposed projects and to advise governments on how to improve renewable energy development in BC. Learn more through the following resources:
- Tamed Rivers: A Guide to River Diversion Hydropower in British Columbia, this 64-page peer-reviewed report goes through the known impacts of river diversion hydropower on fish and wildlife populations, and identifies several areas that require further study
- Building a Vision for Green Energy in British Columbia, November 3-4, 2009, we sponsored and helped organize this Simon Fraser University workshop in efforts to improve planning and management of river diversion hydropower
- Recommendations for Responsible Clean Electricity Development in British Columbia, produced by Watershed Watch, the David Suzuki Foundation, Pembina Institute and West Coast Environmental Law
- Save BC’s Rivers: A river runs through it… but for how long?, a brochure that provides an overview of IPP projects in BC, with a focus on the potential impacts of the project proposed for Bute Inlet
- Run-of-River Hydropower in BC: A Citizen’s Guide to Understanding Approvals, Impacts, and Sustainability of Independent Power Projects, which includes a top-ten list of considerations to determine if a project is sustainable
- “Green” Hydro Power: Understanding Impacts, Approvals, and Sustainability of Run-of-River Independent Power Projects in British Columbia, a more technical and detailed companion report for the Citizen’s Guide above